IF IT FEELS LIKE BAD GOP HEALTHCARE PLANS keep cropping up like
drug-resistant bacteria, you’re not imagining it.
Having discovered that repeal and replace wasn’t as easy as
he thought, President Trump is desperate to get any bill passed, declare
himself tired of winning and get back to doing what he does best. Tweeting
insults.
The latest Republican plan to repeal and replace Obamacare,
reduce money spent on healthcare, but still miraculously cover everyone covered
now, is wobbling along in the U.S. Senate.
Meanwhile, Paul Ryan and Mitch McConnell, with an assist
from Trump—have managed to do what President Barack Obama could never do. No. I
don’t mean take away all our guns. Remember how that was going to happen! Last we
checked everyone still had the guns they had on Inauguration Day in 2009. In
fact, gun sales boomed while Obama was seated in the White House.
Paranoia, I think it was. (Conservatives probably thought you
needed more guns to stop gay weddings.)
As I was saying, GOP leaders have made Obamacare more popular
than ever. We liberals readily admit the law is imperfect. And, as sure as you
mention thermometers (climate change) math (monthly job growth) or polls
(pretty much every approval poll taken since Trump sat down in the Oval Office),
this one will probably not be believed by our friends glued to Fox News.
Here are recent polls on the favorability of Obamacare in
graphic form:
HAVING VENTED A LITTLE, I feel better—which is good,
because we’re going to have to take better care of ourselves once this new
Trumpcare plan goes into effect. We don’t know exactly how many Americans will
lose coverage, or exactly when the worst features will fully take hold.
We just know the Graham-Cassidy bill currently being
discussed by the Senate is decidedly unloved.
Sponsored by Senator Lindsay Graham of South Carolina and Senator
Bill Cassidy of Louisiana, this looks like the Republicans’ last chance to
repeal and replace. Cassidy, for one, has been insisting his bill passes “the
Jimmy Kimmel test.” That is: it will ensure that less-fortunate Americans whose
children are born with severe health problems receive the care families require.
Kimmel, the late night talk show host, has a young son with serious heart
problems. In his case, he makes clear he has good coverage himself. He can pay.
He’s rich. But Kimmel worries about families whose resources are slim.
Or none.
Senator Cassidy claims the latest Trumpcare plan passes
that test.
Kimmel says, emphatically, it does not. He says Cassidy “lied
right to my face” when he told him it did.
How bad is this plan?
Let’s try a test (not covered under the new Republican plan).
Imagine you have a parent or grandparent suffering from long-term effects of
Alzheimer’s disease. They need fulltime help.
Wouldn’t the American Association of Retired Persons (AARP)
support a good healthcare bill?
AARP hates this plan.
Okay. Babies might not be covered. (The American Academy of
Pediatrics calls
Graham-Cassidy “dangerous” and “ill-conceived.”)
And grandpa and grandma might be screwed.
How about this? You have a heart problem and bills are piling
up. The American Heart Association blasts the GOP plan.
“I think the odds have improved,” Senator John Thune told
reporters yesterday. He thinks this bill can pass. “I just told Bill Cassidy he’s
kind of the grave robber,” Thune added. “This thing was six feet under, and I
think he’s revived it.”
Mentioning Trumpcare and graves in the same breathe might
not be the best metaphor one could select.
Take cancer. The lobbying arm of the American Cancer
Society is opposed.
Got a six-year-old with type-1 diabetes? The Juvenile
Diabetes Research Foundation believes the plan is a mess.
Are you an overweight or obese adult? Ha, ha. Of course you
are. Seven in ten American adults weigh way
too much. Suffering from type-2 diabetes, are you, now? The American Diabetes
Association says vote “no” on the bill.
Your husband has lung cancer? The American Lung Association
is opposed.
Your cousin is suffering the terrible effects of Lou Gehrig’s
disease? The ALS Association considers the plan a joke.
The list
(several are combined and linked below) goes on and on—with groups interested
in pretty much every part of the body, from our heads to our toes, calling for the
Senate to vote down the plan. These groups have come out against this last
ditch Trumpcare-don’t care plan:
American Academy of Family Physicians
American College of Physicians
American Congress of Obstetricians and Gynecologists
American Osteopathic Association
American Psychiatric Association (“this bill harms
our most vulnerable patients”)
American Public Health Association (the bill would “devastate”
Medicare)
America’s Essential Hospitals
American Health Care Association/National Center for
Assisted Living (“this bill will undermine care for vulnerable seniors and
individuals with disabilities”)
Arthritis Foundation
Association of American Medical Colleges
Catholic Health Association of the United States
Children’s Hospital Association
Cystic Fibrosis Foundation
Family Voices
Cystic Fibrosis Foundation
Family Voices
Federation of American Hospitals
HIV Medicine Association
Lutheran Services in America
March of Dimes
National Health Council
Lutheran Services in America
March of Dimes
National Health Council
National Council for Behavioral Health
National Institute for Reproductive Health
National Multiple Sclerosis Society
National Organization for Rare Diseases
National Multiple Sclerosis Society
National Organization for Rare Diseases
Planned Parenthood
Volunteers of America
WomenHeart
Volunteers of America
WomenHeart
Who else hates the GOP bill? The American Medical
Association, speaking for 200,000 professionals, opposes
the Graham-Cassidy plan. They say it violates the first principle of all medical
care: “First, do no harm.”
The American Hospital Association: They don’t like it at
all.
Maybe nurses? Maybe…good grief…the American Nurses
Association wants the plan defeated
too.
Blue Cross Blue Shield? They don’t like either. “The bill
contains provisions that would allow states to waive key consumer protections,
as well as undermine safeguards for those with pre-existing conditions,” says the
company president. “The legislation reduces funding for many states
significantly and would increase uncertainty in the marketplace, making
coverage more expensive and jeopardizing Americans’ choice of health plans.”
But, hey, other than that, the plan isn’t bad.
I talked to my daughter recently. She’s head of Newborn
Screening at Children’s National Hospital in Washington, D. C. I asked how work
was going since she just returned from a medical conference in Brazil. She
mentioned meeting doctors from Egypt, Uganda and Rawanda, now that she’s back, to
talk about what her hospital does to help children born with serious, life-threatening
genetic problems. She mentioned one drug that costs $1,000,000 per day. We can all argue about what to
do about ballooning drug costs. (Prices are expected to increase
11.6% in 2017.) But if Senator Cassidy and Senator Graham and Senator Mitch
McConnell and President Trump truly want to help, they can get on the stick and
start fighting to reduce costs today.
Until that day comes—which probably never will—we know
leading professional healthcare groups consider this last GOP hope a contemptible
mess.
Medicare Part D (passed under the last Republican president, has helped balloon healthcare costs. |
Of course we all remember, during the 2016 campaign, how Candidate
Trump promised to protect us from all those illegal immigrant rapists and murderers,
pouring across the border from Mexico.
What we didn’t realize then, once the GOP was in full
control, was that if loved ones developed skin cancer, required kidney
transplants, or suffered catastrophic injuries in automobile accidents, they’d be
pretty much screwed.